Helping sports organization solve integrity, growth, and development challenges

Ethics

Q: Is Violence on the Playing Field A Male Issue?

A:  The environment we create for our children and student-athletes is the result of a complex interplay of numerous social contexts and interactions.  The print and electronic media, major sporting events and, in general, the cultural institution of sport, play a major role in the fabric of the lives of American youth.  Any cultural institution that invites or celebrates male aggression and violence contributes to the problem.  Professional sport in our society does that.  Male violent behavior is not only often unquestioned, it is often celebrated in sport (as it

Q: How can Athletics Directors or Executive Directors of open amateur sports programs help control unnecessary violence in sport?

A:  The real challenge is to ask what can each of us do to clearly integrate for our coaches and student-athletes the notions of aggression, competition and respect for our opponents.  Can we explain the difference between making a clean block or crisp tackle and initiating body contact with the intent to maim?  Can we remove hate language and the denigration of any group from the locker room (and classroom, and hallways) and make it clear that both are unacceptable?  Change occurs one person at a time with one small act at a time.  Which of the following can you do

Q: Is intentionally violating a governance association rule, such as committing a recruiting rule violation, grounds for dismissal

Yes, definitely. There should be a clear written policy that specifically states that any intentional violation of a governance association rule or failure to report a rule violation as soon as the employee becomes aware of such, is grounds for immediate dismissal. Such a provision should be in every coach's employment agreement.  Tolerance for violation of laws, policies and rules creates a deviant organizational climate. Upholding the highest ethical standards is the responsibility of every administrator and a leadership requirement.

Q: Are There Unintended Consequences of the NCAA Academic Progress Rate Requirement?

By Donna Lopiano, President, Sports Management Resources

As academic progress rate (APR) and graduation success rate (GSR) pressures increase on NCAA Division I institutions required to adhere to these rules, we may very well see an increase in unintended consequences on student-athletes and academic support staffs.  History shows that it is impossible to legislate moral integrity.  Make a rule and there are always unanticipated impacts, those who will figure a way around it or live by walking on its gray and hazy edges. 

Q: How does an athletics director control team rules to ensure they are reasonable and avoid litigation?

There should be an athletic department policy that specifies that all 'team rules' or 'codes of conduct' must be approved by the athletics director or his/her designee. That policy should include the following elements:

1. standard provisions that must be included in the team rules of every team such as: